Thursday, November 27, 2008

Are we zombies?


Given the sports (esp. cricket) aficionado I am, it would have been unimaginable to make my blogging debut with a post that does not talk about sports or cricket. However, it was not meant to be. There has been another terrorist strike in India, more specifically Mumbai. I have been tuned in to live Internet broadcast of an Indian news channel since the last 60 hours, also pouring over any news that I can get over news websites. Now I don't live in India at the moment and don't even have an acquaintance being involved in the crisis. But I am anguished, I am tired, I am embarrassed and I am outraged.

Following is a list of major terrorist activities starting from the infamous Mumbai blasts in 1993 which resulted in widespread communal tension & led to riots across the country (Source: wikipedia):
DatePlaceLoss of life
Mar 1993Mumbai257
Feb 1998Coimbatore46
Oct 2001J&K Assembly35
Dec 2001New Delhi Parliament7
Sep 2002Akshardham, Gujarat31
Mar 2003Mumbai train blasts11
May 2003J&K Army camp30
Aug 2003Mumbai car blasts52
Aug 2004Assam16
Oct 2005New Delhi - diwali70
Mar 2006Varanasi21
Jul 2006Mumbai train bombings209
Sep 2006Malegaon, Maharashtra37
May 2007Hyderabad13
Aug 2007Hyderabad42
May 2008Jaipur serial blasts63
July 2008Bangalore2
Sep 2008Delhi21
Oct 2008Agartala4
Oct 2008Imphal17
Oct 2008Assam77
Nov 2008Mumbai185

Besides the fact that the list is shockingly long, I am flabbergasted to see Mumbai facing some of the worst strikes - repeatedly. Mumbai is the financial nerve centre of the country besides being a true reflection of the new & emerging India. Without diminishing the seriousness of any other place being affected by such a demeaning incident, how can we allow a place of such critical importance to the country being exposed to such despicable acts - time and again. What irritates me the most is the proclaimed notion of the 'spirit of Mumbai'. Apparently the city goes back to normalcy after such incidents, and it is elaborately saluted and hailed across the country. Does this really sound worthy of acclaim? C'mon people, the city is not inhabited by zombies who don't feel a thing and keep moving on. I wonder if people are really courageously moving on - I am afraid that they have given up. I wonder if the faces that don't show fear are showing resilience - I am afraid that they have simply turned cold.

Now I am not questioning the enormity of the task and I understand that it may be impossible to 'decimate' extremists harboured by hostile neighbours. But guys - what's new about this - we have known this for donkey years now. If our neighbours are not able to keep their stinking garbage from overflowing and entering our household, we can't keep on cribbing about it and let our house stink. We shut the doors and windows, we get an air freshener, or something else, but we do something about it. Similarly in this case, how much more time do we need to realize that we need to have a more robust security framework in place to ensure:
1) Our borders are not porous to such elements to move in & out of India at pleasure
2) Our intelligence forces are enabled to nip in the bud any such prospective acts
3) Our forces are prepared - in terms of man & material to handle any eventualities
4) Our citizens & more important - our media knows what to do in case of such violence
5) Our emergency services are equipped - medical, fire fighters, traffic, state police to handle such acts
6) We have dedicated teams in at least major cities who are staffed - equipped - trained - and regularly primed with drills, etc. so that they can drastically shorten the time which we take to react and address such eventualities.

Sadly I see no improvement in any of the above every time such an unfortunate incident happens. I always see:
1) Civilians on the spot lifting victims with their limbs - not sure if that makes their injury worse
2) Ambulances/Fire fighters reaching the spot late because of traffic/late communication, etc
3) Policemen on the spot with 303 rifles & no bullet proof vests while miscreants have the most advanced armoury
4) A crowd of people around the site - it not only hampers movement of forces & emergency services but is also a potential hazard
5) Media dramatizing the incidents for TRPs - not only it sounds ridiculous, I suspect it might even provide assistance to the terrorists in terms of security force's movements, position, strength, etc. when they are holed up in hostage situations. Ofcourse the media will say that on such occasions the power, cable, etc. to the hideout are cut, but my dear friends if they can have satellite phones can they not have portable satellite TVs running on batteries. Now I may be wrong but why should we take this chance, expose our forces and inadvertently make a spectacle out of an unfortunate situation. 

Humans are supposed to be the most intelligent species on the planet, and the most important sign of intelligence is one's ability to learn from past mistakes and not repeat them. Hence the phrase "once bitten twice shy". The Mumbai city has had more than its share of suffering in the past few years in form of bombings, riots, floods, and last but not the least the sensex meltdown. It is time that the 'powers to be' understood that even the resilient Mumbaikars have had enough. Looking back at the tumultuous past it has to be said that it is within our means and capabilities to prevent such dastardly incidents from happening again. As India envisages to be a world power, aiming as high as putting an Indian on moon, it only needs a political will to guarantee the most basic of the human rights, the "Right to life".

5 comments:

Patrali said...

couldn't fit the reply here
so here it is.... http://bellsofdervish.blogspot.com/2008/11/reply-to.html

Prabhakar aka Dex said...

I can just hope that this tragic event becomes the last wake up call for all of us.
There are no words in which you can even put the feelings normal indians are feeling right now

http://sharmaprabhakar.blogspot.com/2008/11/blast-from-past.html

Nikhil Gupta said...

Food for thought is what your post is... every word written there is the absolute truth... we indeed should have the right to life and all the things written there in... there should be a fear free world for us to live in...

But you missed out on the biggest reason why this happens... its not because of the ill-equiped forces or the not-so-intelligent intelligence... it is because of the big C word called CORRUPTION...

Trust me on that... without officials at every level aiding these messengers of God as they call themselves... they would never be able to fire one bullet let alone opening fire in public... it pains to learn that corruption has gone to these levels that for money people are willing to let our brothers and sisters die... it really pains. The first step towards fighting terrorism is to fight corruption!

And one point I probably hated you for writing:
"Civilians on the spot lifting victims with their limbs - not sure if that makes their injury worse" - you really mean that??? I mean is it better to let people lay there and die??? Come on mate... that cant be true!

After saying what I wanted to... its a very nice post... very heart touching and true... but we will have to do more than just writing posts my friend!

Sudhakar said...

@Nikhil.. thanks for sharing your thoughts.. my thoughts on your points..
1] I agree the corruption is a big problem in India, but I also think that we (Indians) have made a habit of blaming anything & everything on corruption. Check this list which gives a ranking of corrupt nations: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0781359.html. You would see many nations which are better than India (US, UK, Israel, etc) but still facing terrorism. You would also find nations worse than India but not facing terrorism at all. Now I agree that this argument misses the context different countries face - but that is exactly my argument. Evey country faces some unique challenges, we face corruption, poverty, illiteracy, etc etc. But these inadequacies can not be used as a pretext to condone terrorism which is a much larger menace. In short, the people running the government and administration have to cure the terrorism tumor keeping our socio-economic landscape in mind, and corruption is a part of that, as is poverty, and as is the delicate inter-religion scenario.
2] On the '..civilians lifting victims..'.. I have no intention of taking the credit away from such helpful citizens. But it is a fact too that an inept handling of a victim can actually make his condition more serious. There are reports in the public domain on this issue and I will post some links here if I can. Also you can never be sure if the kind souls helping the victims are actually putting themselves in danger of more disaster to come. In all such situations need a pre-planned rescue strategy in place. So what is important is that the government and administrators take note of this and make provisions for knowledgeable rescuers helping victims under such situations. Apart from ensuring that the medical team reaches the site in a matter of minutes, the administrators can also look at imparting training to groups (NCC, Red Cross, etc) who can be activated in such situations. In-fact some minimal training can even be imparted to students in school, like we are taught the resuscitation techniques to save someone from drowning.

Patrali said...

yup...i agree re.....
but all i'm saying is...let's also not shirk with the herd....n let's buckle up n try to make things fall into place.....let's do it in bits n pieces
a chhota sa step at a time will also go a long way :)
all the best